New Feature: Audio narrations for your stories with Smitten Plus ✨

You were always the quiet one. That's the first thing I noticed about you when I moved in — the way you'd nod at me in the hallway like acknowledging my existence was already too much socializing for

about 2 hours ago
long readhot intensity
You were always the quiet one. That's the first thing I noticed about you when I moved in — the way you'd nod at me in the hallway like acknowledging my existence was already too much socializing for one day. You'd disappear into your room, that door clicking shut with a softness that felt almost passive-aggressive in its precision, and then nothing. Silence. You worked from home, you'd told me that first day, leaning against the doorframe with your arms crossed over a black t-shirt that looked like every other black t-shirt you owned. You valued your peace and quiet, you'd said. I'd laughed and said I'd try to keep it down. I didn't.

That was three months ago, and you've never once complained, even though I know I'm loud. I can't help it. I'm a big guy — fair hair, ruddy skin, the kind of body that takes up space whether it means to or not. I bump into things. I laugh too hard at my own jokes. I cook with every burner on and the radio cranked. And you — tall, lean, pale as paper with that dark hair always falling into your eyes — you just endure it with this look on your face that I've never quite been able to decode. Annoyance? Amusement? Something else?

I think about that look a lot more than I should.

It's a Tuesday in July when the AC dies. I'm in the kitchen making a mess of a stir-fry when the hum of the vents cuts out, replaced by a silence so total it feels like the apartment itself held its breath. The lights flicker once, twice, and then go dark. The range hood dies mid-sizzle. I stand there, spatula in hand, blinking.

"Hey!" I call out, not bothering to moderate my volume. "You lose power in there?"

A pause. Then your voice, dry and measured: "Yes. Obviously."

I grin in the dark. You kill me, honestly. I wipe my hands on a dish towel and fumble my way to the hallway, where I can see the faint glow of your phone screen through the crack under your door. You're probably already looking up the breaker panel. You're probably already three steps ahead of me, the way you always are.

"The panel's in the utility closet by the bathroom," I say, knocking on your door. "You want me to check it?"

Another pause. I can practically hear you weighing the annoyance of a dark apartment against the annoyance of spending time with me. "Fine," you say, and the door opens. You're wearing — surprise — a black t-shirt and black joggers, your hair slightly mussed like you've been running your hand through it. In the dim light from your phone, your skin looks almost luminous. I have to stop myself from staring.

We navigate to the utility closet together, you holding the phone up like a flashlight. The closet is barely a closet — more of a shallow recess behind a louvered door, crammed with the water heater, a tangle of old coat hangers someone left behind, and the breaker panel mounted on the far wall. I squeeze in first, my shoulder brushing the water heater, and you follow me, pulling the door shut behind you out of habit.

It's immediately, absurdly close. The closet was not built for two men, and it was definitely not built for two men when one of them is me. My back is against the wall, my chest nearly level with yours, and the air is already warm — the kind of warm that thickens in seconds when there's no ventilation. Your phone screen goes dark to save battery, and for a moment we're in total blackness, just the sound of our breathing and the faint ticking of the cooling water heater.

"Shit," you mutter, and I feel your arm move as you tap the phone awake again. The screen lights up between us, casting your face in pale blue light, and I realize how close we actually are. Close enough that I can see the individual hairs that have fallen across your forehead. Close enough that when you exhale, I feel it on my collarbone.

"Which breaker do you think it is?" I ask, trying to focus on the panel behind me. My voice sounds strange in here — too loud, too present.

"Could you just — turn around and look?" You gesture at the panel, and there's something in your tone that's not quite impatience. Your eyes are fixed somewhere around my chin, not meeting my gaze.

I turn, which means pressing my back against your chest to get facing the panel, and I hear the small sound you make — barely a breath, but I catch it. Your hands come up to steady me, gripping my hips through my shorts, and the touch sends a jolt through me that has nothing to do with electricity. I don't move. Neither do you.

"I see it," I say, my voice lower than I intended. "Third from the left. It's tripped."

"Flip it."

I reach out and push the breaker. It clicks, and somewhere behind us the AC hums back to life, the lights in the hallway flooding the crack under the door with warm yellow. But in the closet, we're still in shadow, still pressed together, and your hands are still on my hips.

Neither of us moves.

I can feel your heartbeat through your chest, fast and hard against my back. Or maybe that's mine. It's hard to tell when we're this close, when the heat of the closet and the heat of your body and the heat of something I haven't been letting myself name all blur together into one thick, heavy thing.

"You can let go now," I say, but I don't turn around. I don't want to.

Your thumbs shift — just barely, just a fraction of an inch — and I feel them trace along the waistband of my shorts. My breath catches. "Can I?" you ask, and your voice is different now. Quieter. A little rough.

I turn around. We're chest to chest, and I have to look down at you because even though you're tall, I'm broader, and the closet makes me feel even bigger. Your eyes are dark, the phone light catching the edge of your jaw, and you're finally looking at me. Not past me, not through me — at me.

"You've been driving me crazy for three months," I say, and I don't know where the honesty comes from, but it pours out like water through a broken dam. "Every time you shut that door, every time you give me that look like I'm too much — I want to be too much. I want to be too much for you specifically."

You blink. Then the corner of your mouth twitches — not quite a smile, but close. "You're an idiot," you say softly. "I shut the door because if I kept looking at you, I was going to do something about it."

The air in the closet feels like it's vibrating. I reach up and push the hair out of your face, my fingers rough and clumsy, and you lean into the touch like you've been waiting for it. Your skin is cool against my warm palm, and I think about that contrast — me, always hot, always flushed, always too big and too loud; you, always cool, always still, always holding something back — and how right it feels to be pressed together in this dark, stupid little closet.

"I'm going to kiss you now," I say. "Unless you have an objection."

"Shut up, Cody," you say, and you kiss me first.

Your mouth is hot despite the coolness of your skin, and the kiss is deliberate, controlled — like everything you do. You kiss me like you've been planning it, like you've had three months to think about exactly how you wanted this to go. I groan against your lips, and I feel you smile. You're smiling. I've never seen you smile like that, and it makes me want to tear something open.

I press you back against the louvered door, and it rattles in its frame. My hands find the hem of your black t-shirt — of course it's black, always black — and I pull it up, breaking the kiss just long enough to drag it over your head. Your chest is lean and pale, and in the dim light I can see the faint definition of your ribs, the dark line of hair trailing down from your navel. I run my hands over you, rough and eager, and you shiver.

"You're warm," you say, like it's an observation, like you're cataloguing data.

"You're not," I say, and I press my mouth to your collarbone. You taste clean, slightly salty, and I want more. I want all of it.

Your hands find the bottom of my shirt — a ratty old gym shirt that's probably seen better days — and you yank it off with more force than I expected. The air hits my skin, but it's not cooling anything down. Your palms spread flat against my chest, and I watch your face as you feel me — the breadth, the soft give of my body, the hair that covers my pecs and trails down my stomach. Your expression is intent, focused, like you're memorizing something.

"I've wanted to do this since the day you moved in," you say, and your voice is barely above a whisper. "You were carrying boxes in a tank top and you were sweating and I thought —" You stop yourself, shaking your head.

"You thought what?"

"I thought I was fucked."

I laugh — too loud, too big, the way I always do — and you pull me back in, kissing me harder this time, your tongue sliding against mine with a hunger that makes my knees weak. I can feel you getting hard against my thigh, and I shift my weight, pressing my leg between yours, and you gasp into my mouth. The sound goes straight through me.

"Tell me what you want," I say against your lips.

You pull back just enough to look at me. Your eyes are wide, your lips swollen, your hair a mess. You look wrecked already, and we've barely started. "Everything," you say. "I want — God, Cody, I want your mouth on me."

I drop to my knees in the narrow closet, and the floor is hard and probably disgusting, and I don't care. I look up at you and your breath is coming fast now, your hands braced against the door behind you. I reach for the waistband of your joggers and pull them down — no underwear, and the thought makes my cock throb — and you're there, hard and flushed and perfect against the pale of your body.

I take you in my hand first, stroking slowly, and you make a sound that I want to record and play back every day for the rest of my life. Then I lean in and take you in my mouth, and your hand comes down to grip my hair, and you say my name like it's the only word you know.

You taste like salt and skin, and I work you slowly, using my tongue, taking my time because I know you've been waiting for this and I want to make it last. I'm good at this — I know I am — and I can tell by the way your thigh muscles tense under my palms, by the way your breathing goes ragged and uneven, by the way you keep trying to thrust deeper and then stopping yourself like you're afraid of being too much.

"Stop holding back," I say, pulling off just long enough to speak, and you let out a sound that's almost a laugh.

"You have no idea how much I'm holding back."

I take you deeper, and you stop holding back. Your hips move, your hand tightens in my hair, and I feel you hit the back of my throat and I swallow around you. You're shaking, and I can tell you're close, so I pull off — not yet, not yet — and you make a sound of protest that dissolves into a moan when I press my face against your inner thigh, breathing you in.

"Turn around," I say, and my voice is rough.

You look down at me. "What?"

"Turn around. Face the door."

You do, slowly, and I'm looking at the long pale line of your back, the curve of your ass, and I run my hands up the backs of your thighs. You shudder. I spread you open and lean in, and when my tongue finds you, you curse — loud, graceless, the first truly undignified sound I've ever heard you make.

I work you open with my tongue, slow and deliberate, and you're trembling against the door, your palms flat on the wood, your head hanging forward. "Fuck," you say, and then again, "fuck, Cody, that's — Jesus —" I love the way you fall apart. I love the way your composure dissolves, the way your voice cracks, the way your body shakes. I love reducing you to this.

When I finally pull back, you're breathing like you've run a mile, and you turn to look at me over your shoulder with eyes that are completely undone. "I need you," you say. "Right now. I need you inside me."

I stand, my knees aching, and I pull you against me. "Here?"

"Here. Anywhere. I don't care."

I reach past you and open the door, and cool air rushes in, and you blink in the sudden light. The hallway is empty, the apartment quiet, the AC humming its low mechanical song. I take your hand — and that feels significant somehow, holding your hand — and lead you to my bedroom. It's the messiest room in the apartment, clothes on the floor, bed unmade, and you give me a look that's half-disgust, half-fond.

"Charming," you say.

"Shut up and get on the bed."

You do, and I grab the lube from the nightstand — because I'm an optimist, even when I shouldn't be — and I prep you with my fingers, watching your face as I do. You're on your back, legs spread, and you're watching me right back with that same intense focus, like you're memorizing every detail.

"Turn over," I say. "I want you on your hands and knees."

You roll over without argument, and the sight of you — long and lean and pale, presented for me, waiting — makes my chest tight. I slick myself and press against you, and you drop your head between your arms and breathe out.

"Ready?"

"Just fuck me, Cody."

I push in, slow and steady, and we both groan. You're tight and hot around me, and I have to pause, have to breathe, because I'm not going to last if I don't calm down. You shift your hips, impatient, and I feel you clench around me and I almost lose it.

"Stop that," I say, and you laugh — actually laugh — and it's the most beautiful sound I've ever heard.

I start to move, and the pace builds, and you're pushing back against me, meeting every thrust. The bed is creaking and the headboard is hitting the wall and I know — I know — that I'm being too loud, but I can't stop. You're saying things under your breath, fragmented and raw, my name mixed with profanity, and I reach around and take your cock in my hand and stroke you in time with my thrusts.

"Luke," I say, and my voice breaks on your name. "I'm close."

"Me too," you gasp. "Don't stop — don't — fuck —"

I feel you come first, your whole body tightening, and the sensation pushes me over the edge. I bury myself deep and let go, and the world goes white and silent for a long, perfect moment.

After, I collapse beside you, and we're both panting, and the AC is still humming, and the room smells like sex and sweat, and I'm pretty sure I left the stir-fry on the stove but I can't bring myself to care. You're on your stomach, your face turned toward me, and you're looking at me with an expression I've never seen before — soft, open, almost surprised.

"That was —" you start.

"Incredible? Earth-shattering? The best experience of your adult life?"

"I was going to say 'messy.'"

I laugh, and you smile, and I pull you against me. You resist for half a second — old habits — and then you settle in, your head on my chest, your cool skin against my warm skin, and I think about how we fit. How my excess and your restraint somehow make sense together.

"So," I say. "Does this mean you'll stop shutting your door?"

You're quiet for a moment. Then: "I'll stop shutting it when you learn to cook without using every burner."

"Deal."

"And maybe —" You trace a pattern on my chest with your fingertip, and I can tell you're choosing your words carefully, the way you always do. "Maybe you could be loud. Just not before nine. I have calls."

I press a kiss to the top of your head. "I'll see what I can do."

The AC hums. The lights stay on. And for the first time in three months, the apartment feels like it belongs to both of us.